What
is an Orchestra?
The
term “ORCHESTRA” has many meanings and can evoke
a variety of associations. Even a traditional symphony orchestra
is regarded by some people as a collection of instruments
and players, while others consider the orchestra to be an
instrument in itself. There are good arguments for both viewpoints.
On the one hand, a great number of musicians and diverse types
of instruments are involved. On the other hand, what primarily
impresses the composer, the concert audience may not be the
individuals and their parts of the music, but rather how they
unite as a tonal, harmonious, melodic whole.
If we ask a member of the orchestra to play his part alone
for half a minute, the music is often unrecognizable. The
fragment might be taken from one of our favorite symphonies,
yet it can sound add and vague. In much music, only one or
two parts at a time produce the melodies we remember; the
other parts are busy building up harmonies, accentuating rhythms,
and filling out the tonal palette. Hearing them separately
makes it hard to understand their context.
A detached melody part, too, occasionally sound strange. Most
music lovers are familiar with the beginning of the finale
in Tchaikovsky’s Pathetique symphony. But actually the
violins play quite different melodies. Only when they are
heard together do we realize that the combination is the well
known, continuous melody line.
Thus,
we have strong reasons for thinking of the orchestra as a
single instrument. An obvious parallel is a large organ, whose
distinctive stops—the registers—nobody would call
it a separate instrument. Strictly speaking, every pipe in
the organ is its own instrument!
The organ, of course, is played by one person. Some of us
may want to speak of an orchestra only when several musicians
participate. As an extreme case, take the street-bucker with
a harmonica strapped in front of his mouth, a guitar in his
hand, cymbals between his elbow and body, and a bass drum
on his back with a cord to his foot. Is this an orchestra?
We might insist that four different musicians would have to
be playing the instruments. Nonetheless, it has been termed
a “one-man orchestra”. Whatever our attitude,
the above examples illustrate the difficulty of finding clear
definitions.
The
Restaurant Trio
Things
become even more complicated if we compare orchestras for
“serious” music with those for entertainment,
dance and jazz. To call a string quartet, quintet or sextet
an orchestra would probably never occur to us. Such groups
are known as chamber ensembles. Yet in the genres of “light”orchestra
is simply a group—large or small—of musicians
who play together. Even the restaurant trios of yesteryear
could be commanded as follows: "Headwaiter, tell the
orchestra to play Schubert’s military march!"
The
Question of Size
Fifteen
musicians seem a lot for a jazz or dance orchestra, here,
the common term is a “big band”. But if a classical
orchestra includes the same number of players, it is called
a chamber orchestra, for the opposite purpose of emphasizing
its small format. Indeed, a chamber orchestra with fifteen
musicians is almost tiny!
So where does the border run between symphony and chamber
orchestra? Once again, no strict rule exists. At times, it
even depends on the kind of music being played. Many of Haydn’s
symphonies are written for a group of bowed instruments along
with two oboes, two horns, and occasionally a couple of kettledrums.
This is certainly a symphony orchestra, in fact the very prototype
of one. It’s the amount of 20-25 musicians, though,
that constitutes a chamber orchestra by modern standards.
The
Ensemble
A
chamber orchestra can be more easily distinguished from a
chamber ensemble. Frequently an ensemble is defined as a group
in which every musician performs an individual part, whereas
some parts in an orchestra are choral: the same part is played
by several musicians, like the singers in a choir. For example,
Schubert’s Octet gives separate music to each player,
but his symphonies—which may themselves resemble chamber
music—present the string parts chorally to balance the
wind instruments.
A
Title With Traditions
In
sum, it is impossible to unambiguously state what an orchestra
is, or distinguish it from other musical groups. The concept
of an orchestra is elusive, and we should instead focus upon
the word, originally this had nothing to do with musicians
or their instruments. In ancient Greece, an orchestra meant
the forepart of an amphitheatre’s stage, or the area
between the public and the rounded front edge of the stage.
It was there that the chorus acted and danced. The Greek word
Khoros also meant a place for dancing. Hence, the words “chorus”
and “orchestra” have a common background.
Did
the Greek organize musical groups that were similar to later
ensembles or orchestras? Presumably not. Their main stringed
instrument, the soft kithara, and their sharp oboe-like aulos
were too different to sound well together. Still more important,
the two kinds of instruments contrasted in symbolic and religious
significance. To combine them was, therefore, hardly desirable.
As
late as the 17th century, an orchestra was the place in front
of the scene where musicians sat to accompany operas. Not
before some way into the 1700’s did musical groups begin
to be termed orchestra, both in the theatre and elsewhere.
|
|